Student A produced the following piece of writing in response to her teacher delivering instruction on CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.9-10.3: Analyze how complex characters develop over the course of a text, interact with other characters, and advance the plot or develop the theme.
“The Islamic Revolution affected Marjane as a female in Iran. In the book Persepolis on page 3 panel 4 it shows Marjane at a young age where she was forced to wear a veil. It affected her as a girl because the veil had to be worn by women all ages, whether they wanted or not. Marjane was forced to wear something she did not want to wear at a young age.”
Student A was a ninth grade female English Language Learner whose school population was almost 70% Latino. This student is NOT fictional.
Her teacher took on the task of deconstructing the standard using The Core Deconstructed® process.
Student A’s teacher explains her actions here. Specifically, a few highlights of her actions in her own words were the following:
- I modeled my table after a few from Dr. Brown’s book.
- I numbered each cell in the matrix with the idea that this would make targeted instruction for small groups easier to illustrate in my lesson plans.
- I tracked students’ progress towards mastery of this standard over the course of a unit.
Student A produced the following piece of writing in response to the same standard mentioned above after her teacher deconstructed the standard using The Core Deconstructed® process.
“The government has control over individuals, but it’s not strong enough to determine your destiny. Many people think that the government controls them but in reality, they make their own decisions without them realizing. For example, in The House of the Spirits, Pedro Tercero always made his own decision by choosing his way instead of the governments’. In page 154 it says, “And so it was the one day Esteban Treuba, who was resting on the terrace after lunch, heard the boy singing about a bunch of hens who had organized to defeat the fox.” This story, the fox and the hens, represent those people who decided to make their own decisions and go against the government, these people don’t depend on the government at all and it doesn’t influence their decisions or destiny.”
Please note that Student A’s work is unedited for the purpose of emphasizing her improvements.
As the teacher reflected on her actions and student outcomes, she noted that,
- I found that this system makes it easier for teachers to see the big picture and build towards the Practitioner/Expert level over the course of a few lessons rather than overwhelm students or unintentionally instill a sense of defeat in them
- I can link websites with enrichment or re-teaching exercises, online games, web-based assessments or supplemental texts to each cell in the matrix. This will enhance my ability to more effectively target instruction in my diverse classes.
- Students were able to see their need to master one objective before they could master the next objective
- I was able to pinpoint exactly where students were struggling in the process of mastering a standard which is essential not only for a data-driven school, but also for students.
- Teaching with the deconstructed standard led to great reflective discussions in teacher-student conferences, as students were able to see their progress and reflect on exactly where they were struggling.
Finally, the teacher stated, “The beauty of this system is that each teacher can tailor the results of the process to their own teaching style and the needs of their individual students.”
Have you deconstructed the core? If not, I challenge you-as I did the teacher of Student A-to start now.